I was just thinking that as a sufficient condition, rather then a necessary condition. It doesn't rule out moonless planets. I was thinking if an object has a strong enough gravity field to hold a stable moon within it's Hill Sphere, it's more then a small asteroid.
Cometary debris clouds are not stable, and are either blown off, creating the tail, or fall back to the surface as the comet heads back to the outer solar system.
The definition also includes the condition that it's orbiting a star, so brown dwarfs are still "up in the air" as it were ^_^
That, and it's a lot easier to change the definition, then to admit that they've be wrongly calling it a planet for the past 75 years.
no subject
Date: 16 Aug 2006 15:26 (UTC)Cometary debris clouds are not stable, and are either blown off, creating the tail, or fall back to the surface as the comet heads back to the outer solar system.
The definition also includes the condition that it's orbiting a star, so brown dwarfs are still "up in the air" as it were ^_^
That, and it's a lot easier to change the definition, then to admit that they've be wrongly calling it a planet for the past 75 years.